Last night, I watched the first episode of “The Amandas”, a new organizing show about Amanda LeBlanc who runs an organizing business in Birmingham, AL.
She has style, great organizing solutions, and the worst case of OCD I have ever seen! She made her daughters late to school because she just HAD TO refill the sugar container in the kitchen and make sure there was a spoon in it “just so” before she could leave the house – yikes!
Well, you figure someone with OCD would be a great organizer, and she is – but man, would it suck to work for her! She employs 5 ladies as organizers, and they all wear dresses and high heels to work. To work IN. HIGH heels, like 4-6″ high! And they all talk about how they have ruined dresses and designer shoes wearing them to work (Here’s a tip for you, ladies – DON’T WEAR your Manolos to rip up floor tiles – DUH!).
As if that’s not bad enough, she makes a schedule for every detail of a job down to the minute, and according to her employees, she underestimates how long things will take, so she’s always on their cases about being behind. She got so upset with everyone on last night’s show for being behind that she gathered everyone together and cried because they were going to “look like fools” if they didn’t finish on time. So, of course, everyone straightened up and got the job done on time and the clients were happy and it was fabulous.
UG! Too much drama for me. Mind you, all the drama came from the ORGANIZERS, NOT from the clients. The clients were the happiest people on the show! No boo-hooing over having to go through their closets and purge, no complaining about getting kicked out of their house for 3 days while the work was being done, nope, not a negative word out of these guys!
Okay, I get it – this show is all about how crazy OCD Amanda is, and how beautiful her employees are, and how hard they work and how many fancy clothes they ruin to do a beautiful job for the clients. I’m not really sure if I want to keep watching this annoying show or not…
Speaking of organizing shows, here’s my opinion of some of the other ones out there:
Hoarders: I HATE THIS SHOW! First of all, it isn’t really so much an organizing show as it is a Freak Show. People like to watch it for the shock value, that look behind closed doors of lives gone horribly wrong. It is just sad, creepy voyeurism.
Secondly, they try to tackle waaaaay too much in a short period of time. I mean, this person’s entire house is literally filled with clutter and they try to fix it all in a few days??? There’s all these people (and cameras) in their house, invading their space and calling their stuff “junk” and telling them to get rid of it. Then the hoarder either starts having cursing fits and crying breakdowns – wouldn’t you too?
The shrinks on this show always say hoarding is a “disease”, just like alcoholism or drug addiction. I agree with that analogy – something bad happened to these people and now they do this thing to feel better or safe. But then the docs expect the hoarders to “go cold turkey”? To just “snap out of it” and start purging all the crap they’ve been living with for the past however-many years?
Usually by the end of the show, they’ve managed to get one or two rooms semi-cleared out, but that’s it. A good start, with lots more work and therapy for the hoarder. It always leaves me with a bad taste in my mouth, like as soon as the crew leaves, this poor person is doomed to fall back into old habits. This show would be so much better if they continued filming the entire process, over months or years or however long it takes, so that we get to see the entire transformation and are left with a better feeling at the end.
neat: Canada’s organizing and makeover show is hosted by Hellen Buttegieg, who seems very nice and smiley and oh so Canadian, but she does always manage to work in a few snarky comments with that smile. One thing I do like about this show is they only try to tackle a few rooms at a time. It is more manageable and more doable than the “whole house” approach. Hellen and her Clean Team show up and empty the room and lay it all out (nice!) so the homeowners can go through it and decide what to keep and what to purge. Hellen always comes up with cutesy names for the bins, such as “Present” (keep) and “Past” (purge).
A couple things about her approach irritate me: She stands there with the homeowners, going through every single piece of stuff with them. When the homeowner (usually a woman) wants to keep something for “sentimental reasons”, Hellen starts giving her the 3rd degree like: “Why do you feel the need to keep this item?”; “How will keeping this item make your life better?”; “Is this item worth the space it’s taking up to keep it?” This is usually the part of the show where Hellen makes the woman cry. I mean, sometimes you just want to keep a souvenir because you want it! You shouldn’t have to justify it to the mean Canadian organizer lady!
And sometimes, if Hellen feels that the homeowners are not purging enough, she’ll tell them in her passive-agressive way that unless they purge X% of their stuff, she won’t be able to give them the room that they want. Essentially, she’s making it their fault if SHE fails at what they hired her to do!
I do like that she explains several storage solutions and organizing tips throughout each show. And for the most part, her makeovers are pretty livable. She does seem to organize things so they “just fit”, with not too much room for growth, and then implements the “one in, one out” rule, which means if you buy a new one (book, blouse, etc), then you have to get rid of an old one “to keep the balance” (because there isn’t enough room).
I enjoy watching this show for the tips and tools, plus they do give you great befores and afters, but I will always think of her as the “mean Canadian organizer lady”!
Extreme Clutter: Peter Walsh, who we first met on the show “Clean Sweep”, has a new organizing show on the Oprah Winfrey Network called “Extreme Clutter”. The first episode I watched of this was the notorious Mackenzie Phillips episode – so riveting!
I *LOVE* Peter Walsh! Why? Because he’s a good organizer, yes. But also, because he seems so genuinely interested in helping people live better, more organized, more clutter-free lives. He tries to help people figure out the reasons for their clutter, to understand it so they can conquer it. To know their “clutter” enemy in order to defeat it.
I like his new verbage for keeping things and purging them: he says you have to “create a vision for the room”, and then only the keep the things that fit that vision. (Love it!)
Peter does make people cry, only cry for joy, not cry because he’s berating or belittling them. He creates neat, functional, growable spaces for people. I really like his style, his approach, his philosophy. Peter Walsh is THE MAN!







































